Skip To Content
Free consultation Text or call 312.553.4900

$12 Million Accord Reached in Abuse Case

July 1, 2006  ·  By HM&M



by John Flynn Rooney, staff writer

A $12 million structured settlement was reached in a lawsuit alleging three children were physically abused by a foster mother selected by The Catholic Charities of the Archdiocese of Chicago, lawyers for the children said Friday.

The settlement is expected to approach $55 million over the children’s lifetimes, said Michael T. Mertz. Mertz and Christopher T. Hurley, both principals with [[title]] PC in Chicago, represented the children.

Beginning in 1995, a boy and his two sisters, ages 1, 2 and 3 years old, were placed in foster care with services provided by Catholic Charities, Hurley said on Friday. The parents of the children were drug addicts.

The children were removed from the foster home on May 7, 1997, after the boy went to school with a bruise on his face and recent cigarette burns on his legs and lower body, according to Hurley. Doctors reported that one of the sisters suffered burns on both her hands after they were forcibly placed in boiling water, he added.

The children, now 14, 13 and 11, live with their maternal grandmother in Hempstead, NY, Hurley said.

“You’re taking three kids who have probably had the worst luck I have ever witnessed with any of my clients and we are going to change their lives and give them a chance at normal lives,” Hurley said. The grandmother, Ethel Scott, and the three children are expected to relocate to the Chicago area.

The lawsuit maintained that Catholic Charities placed the children in the care of a nonqualified foster parent, failed to properly investigate the foster home and did not conduct sufficient home visits.

Catholic Charities prepared the foster care licensing information and provided it to the Illinois Department of Children and Family Services, which licenses foster parents, James C. Geoly, a lawyer representing Catholic Charities, said.

“Catholic Charities has a reputation for providing very high quality foster care and our experts were prepared to testify that Catholic Charities definitely acted at, or above, the standard of care for foster care in this case,” said Geoly, a partner with Burke, Warren, MacKay & Serritella PC in Chicago.

Ira M. Levin and Christina Y. Nelson, with Burke, Warren, also represented Catholic Charities.

The settlement agreement was reached Wednesday night following a mediation session conducted by Geoffrey L. Gifford, a principal of Pavalon, Gifford, Laatsch & Marino in Chicago, Hurley said. Ethel Scott etc. v. The Catholic Charities of the Archdiocese of Chicago, No. 01 L 15741.

The case had an early September trial date.

July 1, 2006

$4.5 Million Settlement Reached For Brain Damaged 12 Year Old

CHICAGO DAILY LAW BULLETIN The law firm of Hurley, McKenna & Mertz P.C. has won a $4.5 million settlement on behalf of a 12-year-old boy allegedly born developmentally challenged because doctors failed to perform an immediate cesarean section. The suit alleged that doctors at the now-defunct Columbus Hospital in Chicago failed to adequately monitor Antonio... Read More

July 1, 2006

Catholic Charities Settles Abuse Suit

CHICAGO TRIBUNE Catholic Charities of Chicago on Thursday settled for $12 million a lawsuit alleging that three children were abused by their foster parents, attorneys said. Starting in 1995, the boy and two girls, then ages 1, 2 and 3, were in the care of foster parents licensed by Catholic Charities, said plaintiff’s attorney Christopher... Read More

We don't support Internet Explorer

Please use Chrome, Safari, Firefox, or Edge to view this site.